Dark Shadows

‘Dark Shadows’: Why the Controversial Leviathans Storyline Took the Show in the Wrong Direction

Posted on

For a television series that featured vampires, witches, werewolves, ghosts, time travel and just about every other supernatural menace imaginable, it might seem difficult to believe that one particular storyline could have been too strange for Dark Shadows. Yet that’s precisely what happened in late 1969, when the ABC daytime Gothic soap opera introduced the Leviathans, mysterious beings whose arrival would dramatically alter the lives of Barnabas Collins and the other residents of Collinsport.

The storyline followed one of the most popular periods in the show’s history, an extended adventure set in 1897 that had sent Barnabas, played by Jonathan Frid, into the past and introduced viewers to such memorable characters as Quentin Collins and the sinister Count Petofi. After months of ghosts, curses, witchcraft and supernatural intrigue, audiences were confronted with something quite different: a mysterious cult, children who aged at an alarming rate, a collection of hooded figures and a monstrous creature that was heard far more often than it was seen.

The result was one of the most controversial chapters in the series’ five-year history. And although the Leviathan storyline contained some genuinely exciting moments, it also made what many consider to be one of the show’s greatest mistakes: turning Barnabas Collins, its most popular character, into a weak-willed servant of the very evil he should have been fighting.

What Were the Leviathans?

The Leviathans were supposedly ancient beings who had ruled the world before the dawn of humankind. Their mythology bore a resemblance to the cosmic horrors of H.P. Lovecraft, whose stories frequently involved ancient, powerful entities existing beyond ordinary human understanding.

Lovecraft’s writings were enjoying renewed popularity during the late 1960s and early 1970s, and the show’s writers apparently saw an opportunity to bring something of that atmosphere to Collinsport. Unfortunately, what might have worked in a Lovecraft short story was not necessarily suited to a Gothic soap opera whose audience had grown accustomed to seeing its monsters in action.

The trouble began when Barnabas returned from the past carrying a mysterious wooden box and a book connected to the Leviathans. The box contained an unseen creature whose presence was generally announced by heavy breathing and other unsettling sounds. Its occupant would eventually assume a series of human forms, beginning with a baby and progressing through several increasingly older boys before emerging as Jeb Hawkes. Meanwhile, the Leviathans began establishing themselves in Collinsport through Phillip and Megan Todd, proprietors of an antique shop who became involved in the cult’s activities. Familiar characters also underwent disturbing personality changes as the ancient beings extended their influence.

After three-and-a-half years of Gothic romance, supernatural suspense and occult intrigue, the series had suddenly veered into a pseudo-science-fiction storyline reminiscent of Invasion of the Body Snatchers, I Married a Monster from Outer Space and Rosemary’s Baby.

The ever-sexless Dark Shadows had finally introduced heavy breathing—but it was coming from a carved wooden box whose panting occupant appeared to be some sort of slimy, scaly, dragon-like shape-shifter, better suited to Star Trek or Doctor Who. And the audience never even got a good look at it!

What Happened to Barnabas Collins?

By 1969, Barnabas Collins essentially was the show. Originally introduced as a villainous vampire, he had gradually evolved into a tragic, sympathetic figure whose struggle against his curse made him the emotional center of the series. Jonathan Frid’s performance had helped transform the program into a genuine phenomenon, and viewers had become deeply invested in Barnabas’ relationships with the Collins family and his closest confidante, Dr. Julia Hoffman, played by Grayson Hall.

Which made his behavior during the Leviathan storyline all the more difficult to accept. He returned to the present no longer a vampire, but seemingly without a will of his own. He obeyed mysterious hooded figures and took orders from an assortment of new characters, including the Todds and the children associated with the Leviathans. The once-strong, noble Barnabas was reduced to bowing and scraping before people who possessed little of his intelligence, dignity or complexity.

Worse, he appeared to have lost much of his compassion for Julia, Chris Jennings and even his own relatives, including Quentin, Elizabeth, Roger, Carolyn and David Collins. Instead of the conflicted hero viewers had come to admire, he behaved like an unredeemable fiend.

Even the explanation for his obedience was confusing. At first, Barnabas seemed to be under a supernatural spell and incapable of resisting. Later, the Leviathans claimed to be holding Josette DuPres Collins, the woman he had loved in the 18th century, hostage in the past. But viewers had already witnessed Josette’s death in 1796, when she took poison. Barnabas eventually learned that the Leviathans had been lying to him, but the entire explanation seemed unnecessarily complicated. Why couldn’t he simply have attempted to return to the past and rescue Josette, thereby ending his eternal regrets and longing?

By the time the writers allowed Barnabas to rediscover his backbone, express concern for his family, take Julia into his confidence and resist Jeb Hawkes, much of the damage had been done. Bottom line: making Barnabas the leader of the Leviathan cult was a wrong move. The storyline would have been far more palatable if he had retained his integrity and someone else had become the chief representative of these mysterious beings.

And there was a perfect candidate already living at Collinwood.

Why Roger Collins Should Have Led the Leviathans

Roger Collins, played by Louis Edmonds, was one of the show’s original characters and hardly a model of virtue. When the series began in 1966, Roger was a shady, frequently unscrupulous member of the wealthy Collins family, whose questionable decisions had caused no end of trouble. Yet during the Leviathan storyline, he was largely relegated to the sidelines. As the Collinsport Players later joked in their musical parody Wedding Bells or Death Knells?, Roger never had anything to do in this story. What a waste of both the character and Edmonds’ considerable talents.

Imagine instead that Barnabas had returned from the past temporarily bewitched, bringing the Leviathan box and book with him, but had then passed them into Roger’s possession. With his wealth, prestige, business connections and standing in the community, Roger would have been an ideal choice to lead the cult. A return to his unscrupulous ways would have been much less unsettling than the near destruction of Barnabas’ character. It also would have anticipated the murderous behavior of Roger’s counterpart in the subsequent 1970 Parallel Time storyline, which took place in an alternate reality.

The possibility wasn’t entirely without support from the episodes themselves. Elizabeth Collins Stoddard observed that the family’s money and prestige could further the Leviathan cause, while Jeb Hawkes expressed an interest in bringing Roger into the cult. Why entrust the mysterious box, book and children to the relatively insignificant Todds and their small-time antique shop when the Leviathans could have commanded the resources of the Collins family itself?

Marie Wallace, who portrayed Megan Todd, could still have played a similar character, perhaps as an incarnation of the mysterious Haza who became Roger’s third wife. That would have continued his remarkable tradition of choosing women with supernatural secrets, following the phoenix Laura and the witch Cassandra.

Meanwhile, Barnabas’ spell could have worn off—or been removed through Julia’s hypnosis—shortly after he delivered the Leviathan artifacts to Roger. Barnabas, Julia, Quentin, Maggie Evans and Willie Loomis could then have begun battling the cult without delay. The story would have retained its supernatural menace while allowing its most popular characters to truly be themselves.

The Storyline Wasn’t All Bad

For all its shortcomings, the Leviathan period contained some of the finest moments in the series. Quentin Collins returned to the present, alive and young but suffering from amnesia. His reunion with Amanda Harris, a woman connected to his past, led to a supernatural confrontation with Death itself, as the lovers raced through the netherworld in a story reminiscent of Orpheus and Eurydice.

Chris Jennings continued his desperate efforts to escape his werewolf curse, turning to the mystical abilities of artist Charles Delaware Tate and the dubious powers of a “moon poppy” flower. Nicholas Blair returned with another devilish scheme, while Angelique appeared in 1970 as a mortal woman married to a millionaire whose true nature proved to be something of a surprise.

There were zombies, a vampiress preying upon the Collins family and the eventual restoration of the friendship between Barnabas and Julia. The series was certainly not lacking in supernatural incident.

Most importantly, the storyline improved dramatically with the arrival of Jeb Hawkes, chillingly portrayed by Christopher Pennock. Once Jeb appeared, the action moved more swiftly and there were numerous scenes of genuine excitement. It seems that the story would have been much more compelling if the essence in the wooden box had become Jeb almost immediately, eliminating the approximately eight tedious weeks devoted to the younger forms of the creature. By the time he arrived, viewers who had persevered had grown accustomed to the idea of an unseen “dragon” flying around Collinsport—outlandish even for this show!—and could begin appreciating the storyline’s more satisfying elements.

There were plenty of positives, but they were often obscured by the unnecessarily prolonged introduction and the mishandling of Barnabas.

Did the Leviathans Hurt ‘Dark Shadows’?

The Leviathan storyline has inspired debate and good-natured ridicule among fans for decades. The Collinsport Players spoofed it in Wedding Bells or Death Knells?, performed at the 1987 Newark Dark Shadows Festival. Their later production Double Play, performed at festivals in 1991 and 1993, featured Julia Hoffman accusing Barnabas, “You obviously didn’t watch the Leviathan episodes.”

Barnabas replied, “Who did?”

The joke reflected a genuine division among viewers. Some fans love the storyline, others despise it and many acknowledge its merits while questioning the creative decisions that shaped it.

The show’s ratings had reached their peak during the popular 1897 adventure, and the change in direction that followed coincided with a decline. Many fans believe the Leviathan period contributed to the series’ eventual cancellation in April 1971, although it would be difficult to attribute that decision to a single storyline.

Ironically, the subsequent 1970 Parallel Time saga offered some of the finest writing and characterization in the show’s history, but the question remains whether the Leviathans had already driven away too many viewers. At one point, the writers reportedly considered following the 1897 story with Count Petofi invading the present. Why was that possibility never realized? It’s intriguing to imagine how differently the series might have developed had the writers pursued that idea instead.

The Leviathans were an ambitious experiment, and there are unquestionably worthwhile moments scattered throughout the story. Christopher Pennock’s performance, the return of familiar supernatural characters and the renewed friendship between Barnabas and Julia all helped redeem its later episodes. Nevertheless, the storyline’s peculiar mixture of Gothic horror and science-fiction paranoia never quite fit the established mood of the series. Its greatest failing was not the introduction of ancient monsters, mysterious children or even a heavy-breathing wooden box, but instead the decision to undermine the character who had become the show’s greatest strength.

For a series that had successfully introduced vampires, witches, werewolves and ghosts, the Leviathans should have been just another supernatural challenge for Barnabas Collins. Instead, for far too long, they turned him into someone his audience barely recognized.

Check out our story on Quentin Tarantino and House of Dark Shadows

Screenshot 2026 10 30 At 9.55.28 pm

One thought on “‘Dark Shadows’: Why the Controversial Leviathans Storyline Took the Show in the Wrong Direction”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Blog Listing