Dark Shadows

How Barnabas Collins Transformed ‘Dark Shadows’ From a Struggling Soap Into a Phenomenon — Part 1

Posted on

When Jonathan Frid first appeared as Barnabas Collins on Dark Shadows in April 1967, he had no reason to believe the role would change his life, much less help transform the vampire in popular entertainment. He was a classically trained actor who had spent much of his career on the stage, and this was supposed to be a temporary television job before he headed west to pursue teaching.

Barnabas wasn’t intended to stick around, either. He was a vampire who had spent nearly two centuries imprisoned in a chained coffin, released into the 20th century by Willie Loomis and determined to reclaim the life that had been taken from him. He would terrorize the residents of Collinsport, Maine, and eventually be destroyed, presumably with the traditional wooden stake through the heart.

Instead, something extraordinary happened. Audiences became fascinated with Barnabas, and a character conceived as a villain gradually became the central figure of the series. More significantly, he began exhibiting characteristics that were rarely associated with vampires at the time: guilt, remorse, vulnerability and an awareness of his own monstrous behavior. It was a transformation that would ultimately have repercussions far beyond Dark Shadows. But before Barnabas could change the vampire, he would have to change the television series that introduced him.

A Vampire Comes to Collinwood

Dark Shadows premiered on ABC on June 27, 1966, initially presenting itself as a Gothic mystery centered on Victoria Winters, a young governess who arrived at the imposing Collinwood estate to care for David Collins. The series featured family secrets, romantic entanglements, suspicious characters and an atmosphere suggesting that the past was never entirely dead.

Gradually, the supernatural began moving from suggestion to reality. The ghost of Josette Collins made her presence known, while Laura Collins, David’s mother, was revealed to have a connection to the mythological phoenix. But the introduction of Barnabas took the series into territory no American daytime soap opera had explored quite this way before.

Director John Sedwick, whom I interviewed in January 1984, recalled the importance of treating the increasingly fantastic material seriously.

JOHN SEDWICK: “I think those of us who were connected to it, especially at the beginning, felt that we were doing something different in daytime. TV had not done a mystery-ghost-vampire soap opera before. The soaps usually centered around problems at home, domestic problems, love problems. And Dark Shadows was sort of a new experiment. It actually started as a Nancy Drew type mystery. We did have some ghosts, but it wasn’t until Barnabas arrived nine months into the series that it caught fire, and a lot of that was due to the character and the actor, Jonathan Frid, who portrayed him, and the bizarre concept of a vampire actually existing.”

“We found out early that when we got to the vampire stage, we could not comment on it. We could not camp it up. It had to be treated like a real vampire living in a real mansion, like Collinwood. We had to play it very real without camping it up and making comments on the acting. We couldn’t do what Batman did, with the pows and the zaps. If he bit someone, it was like he would do it in normal life. That was one of the saving graces that made the show as successful as it was.”

Barnabas initially fit the established vampire mold. He preyed upon young women, terrorized Willie Loomis, threatened anyone who might discover his secret and became obsessed with Maggie Evans because of her resemblance to his long-dead love, Josette du Pres.

His treatment of Maggie was particularly cruel. He kidnapped her, imprisoned her in the Old House (where he resided) and attempted to transform her into Josette, forcing her to wear the dead woman’s clothing and adopt her identity. When she resisted, his response was hardly that of a misunderstood romantic hero. Yet audiences responded to him, and particularly to the actor playing him.

JOHN SEDWICK: “He played it very honestly. He had a wonderful, mysterious sort of quality. A larger-than-life quality. He could look evil and exude this vampire-undead mystique. And he enjoyed playing Barnabas; he had a magnitude about him. He had a very great presence when he was just looking and watching. He had great eyes and good thinking contact as an actor.”

Jonathan Frid and the Horror of the Lie

When I interviewed Jonathan Frid at his New York apartment on September 8, 1983, one of the most fascinating aspects of our conversation was his explanation of how he approached Barnabas. Although the character had become synonymous with vampirism, Frid was much more interested in the psychological elements of the role than in its supernatural trappings. His background had prepared him for playing villains, particularly those whose outward behavior concealed complicated emotions.

JONATHAN FRID: “I’ve always played the heavy, and my greatest heavy role, next to Barnabas I suppose, is the ultimate heavy role, although ironically with Barnabas I finally reached my own age in a sense, playing Barnabas at about 40, and he was a romantic man as well as a heavy, so you combined the two things.”

He found the character’s most frightening quality not in his fangs or his appetite for blood, but in the elaborate deception required to conceal his true identity.

JONATHAN FRID: “I love to play horror for horror’s sake. The inner horror—I mean, the fang business with Barnabas—I never thought that I created fear, I always felt foolish doing that part of it, but the horror part I liked was ‘the lie. There’s nothing more horrible than looking someone in the eyes who is telling you a lie, and you know it’s a lie. Especially in a love relationship when you find out the person does not love you and is only pretending. Somehow, that scares me more than anything else. Of course, I’ve never been physically attacked by anyone with a knife or a gun or teeth, and that may be quite horrible [laughs], but in terms of the theater I like the inner drama rather than the outward manifestations. An inner conflict or emotional confrontation is more of a drama to me. That way, with Barnabas, there were many scenes I was thrilled to do and why the show came alive so many times for me. What scared me was Barnabas’ lie; that he was pretending to be something he wasn’t. That was something the actor playing Barnabas had to remember all the time. He got lust for blood every once in a while, but always what preyed on his mind was the lie.”

When I asked whether that was his principal motivation, he connected Barnabas’ deception to his own experience as an actor.

JONATHAN FRID: “That was all I could ever think of and of course it played right into my lie as an actor, pretending to be fully confident when I wasn’t. I was lying that I was calm and comfortable, just as Barnabas was lying that he was the calm and comfortable cousin from England. He wasn’t at all. He was a sick, unbelievable creep that the world didn’t know about.”

Interestingly, Frid didn’t necessarily agree with the suggestion that Barnabas had undergone a transformation from evil to good.

JONATHAN FRID: “I don’t mean whether he was nice or bad. He was always nice, right from the beginning. He was never really bad. What was really bad was the lie. The little boy, David, recognized that horror of Barnabas; David would say, ‘There’s something wrong’ and he would be scared by it. Dennis Patrick as Jason McGuire also sensed that there was something.”

“I think that Barnabas is very much like everything I’ve played before. I played Macbeth once, and there’s a great similarity between Barnabas and Macbeth. The guilt. And ultimately, Richard III’s guilt. I don’t really like to drag Richard into that, because a lot of people think he had no guilt at all, and I think he did. But certainly Macbeth is built on guilt, just as Barnabas was built on guilt. They’re very similar types of roles.”

Dark Shadows, Jonathan Frid, Grayson Hall, 1966 71
Dark Shadows, Jonathan Frid, Grayson Hall, 1966 71

The character’s vulnerability was also influenced by something Frid hadn’t anticipated: the extraordinary demands of performing in a daily television series. Unlike the theatrical productions to which he was accustomed, Dark Shadows required enormous amounts of dialogue to be learned and performed with very little preparation time. Frid found the experience almost overwhelming.

JONATHAN FRID: “If I say nothing else important during this interview, every day of my first year on the show was sheer hell. I was incredibly nervous, but it worked for Barnabas, because the character was a nervous wreck.”

A Monster Who Couldn’t Remain a Monster

The character’s unexpected popularity created an opportunity for the writers, but also a problem. Barnabas had been introduced as a temporary villain, and there were limits to how long he could continue terrorizing Collinsport without becoming repetitive. Writer Ron Sproat, who helped shape the character during the series’ early supernatural period, explained the challenge.

RON SPROAT: “We just felt we couldn’t get that much mileage out of a character who is pure evil. It isn’t interesting anyway. When you’re dealing with two and a half hours a week and you’re seeing a lot of the character, it just has to have more dimension than that. Even the villain has to have different colors other than snarling and snapping. In fact, in the book Dracula, Dracula hardly appears at all. He’s in the beginning and the end, but most of it’s the search for him.”

Dark Shadows
Dark Shadows

Sproat’s observation touches on an important distinction between a traditional vampire story and a continuing television drama. In Bram Stoker’s novel, Dracula is the central threat, but much of the narrative concerns the efforts of other characters to understand and destroy him. Dark Shadows, on the other hand, was increasingly asking viewers to spend time with Barnabas himself, five days a week. He couldn’t simply emerge from the shadows, attack someone and retreat to his coffin indefinitely. The character needed relationships, conflicts and an emotional life that could sustain continuing stories.

Some of those elements were already taking shape before the series eventually ventured into the past. Dr. Julia Hoffman, introduced as a physician investigating the mysterious blood disorder afflicting Maggie Evans, discovered Barnabas’ secret and eventually began experiments intended to cure his vampirism. Her efforts offered him something he hadn’t possessed since his transformation: the possibility of becoming human again.

There was also the ghost of his younger sister, Sarah Collins, whose appearances suggested that the man Barnabas had once been might still exist somewhere within the vampire. His anguish over Sarah and his desire to see her again revealed an emotional vulnerability that contrasted sharply with his cruelty. And his developing attachment to Victoria Winters, whom he initially viewed as another potential replacement for Josette, began to complicate his predatory instincts.

These developments didn’t erase his crimes or suddenly turn him into a hero. But they gave him reasons to resist his darker impulses, even when he was unable to overcome them. The writers were gradually discovering that Barnabas could be much more than a monster.

The Vampire Who Changed the Show

House Of Dark Shadows, Jonathan Frid, Kathryn Leigh Scott, 1970.
House Of Dark Shadows, Jonathan Frid, Kathryn Leigh Scott, 1970 (courtesy the Everett Collection)

By the autumn of 1967, Barnabas Collins had already transformed Dark Shadows. What had begun as a Gothic mystery centered on Victoria Winters was now a supernatural serial whose most compelling character was a vampire. And the character’s popularity had forced a fundamental change in how he was written. Barnabas was still dangerous, still capable of terrible acts, but he was also increasingly vulnerable, guilt-ridden and desperate to escape the condition that defined him.

Frid’s performance had helped make that transformation possible, while the demands of a continuing drama encouraged the writers to explore aspects of the character that had never been part of the original plan. But one enormous question remained unanswered: Who had Barnabas Collins been before he became a vampire?

Viewers knew that he had loved a woman named Josette and that he had spent nearly two centuries imprisoned in a coffin. They knew he was tormented by memories of a life that had been taken from him, but the circumstances of his transformation, and the human being he had once been, remained largely mysterious. The writers were about to answer those questions in a way that would change both Barnabas and Dark Shadows forever.

In November 1967, Victoria Winters would find herself transported to the year 1795, where the Collins family was about to experience a tragedy whose consequences would reach across the centuries. And audiences would finally meet Barnabas Collins—the man before the monster.

Next: How Dark Shadows Created the Sympathetic Vampire — The Barnabas Collins Story, Part Two, coming soon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Blog Listing